By Danielle La Londe

Eclogue 4 has delighted and perplexed readers for over two thousand years. Its vivid descriptions of nature’s fantastical wonders engage the senses while it tantalizes readers with the promise of a new age and a question of who the miraculous child it celebrates could be. The poem opens with the poet summoning himself to a loftier topic than herdsmen’s songs of the previous three Eclogues. This loftier song will be a prophecy from the Cumaean Sibyl, an important female prophet in Roman religion. Thus, when Vergil mentions a returning Golden Age, an unprecedented idea thus far in the literature of Greece and Rome, the reader is hooked. What is this Golden Age? How could such a time from the deep recesses of mythic ages return? Why is this event a topic worthy of the political leaders of Rome (the poem is addressed to one of the consuls, the highest elected political office in Rome) and why is it a song of the Cumaean Sibyl, whose books of prophecies have long been consulted during times of national crisis? The goal of this introductory essay is to equip the reader with the context needed to not only recognize the poem’s literary and historical contexts but more importantly find their own meaning in the poem. This overview aims to connect the political events and cultural context of the time to the poem’s language, imagery, and themes. It consists of six sections: I. Poem Summary, II. Historical Context: The Treaty of Brundisium, III. The Pastoral Tradition and Theocritus, IV. The Golden Age, and V. Prophecy and Rebirth.

Poem Summary

The opening verses announce that this poem, while still pastoral, will be more elevated in tone, worthy of a consul (verses 1–3); it celebrates the arrival of the prophesied Golden Age when the divinities Justice and Saturn return, and a new human race will be sent from the heavens (4–7). All this will come to pass when a male child is born, whose birth will cause the iron race to depart and the golden race to return (8–17).

Lucina, goddess of childbirth, will watch over the boy (verse 10) and the Golden Age will begin under the consul Pollio. The poem then identifies three central features of the Golden Age that brings with it a golden race of men: 1) it is a time free from fear and vice (11–14); 2) gods, mortals, and mythical heroes share company (15–16); and 3) the child will grow up to rule the world in peace (17). These features are elaborated upon through the recurring motifs of spontaneous natural bounty (18–20); livestock are fertile and safe from predators (21–23); and men will neither need nor desire to compete for resources and power, freeing them from the vices and corruption that cause war.

Throughout the poem the child’s three life stages are linked to three stages of the unfolding Golden Age. In stage 1, infancy (verses 18–25), the natural world reacts to the dawning Golden Age with idyllic bounty and peace. Plants grow untended by the farmer, and traditional hazards (lions, snakes, poisonous plants) will not be a threat. In stage 2, adolescence (26–36), men are capable of greatness but still exhibit vice. The mythical heroic age is repeated, and yet some violations of the natural order by human technologies will persist, such as property boundaries, ships, and farming, culminating in the worst of human technologies, war, here, a second Trojan war. When the child is an adult, Stage 3 (37–45), the Golden Age will be fully realized: nature will be bountiful, agriculture will be unnecessary, and man will no longer require technologies to control the natural environment.

The poem concludes by returning the reader to the larger cosmic framing and significance of this prophesied age. Just as the poem opened with references to divinities and their celestial abode, so hither we return as the poet sings of the Fates spinning the lives of men and praising the child as a sprout or seed of Jupiter, in whose presence the earth, oceans, and sky will all tremble (verses 46–52). At verses 53–59 the poet reminds his audience that he is worthy of the poetic task by declaring himself to be the greatest of all poets, who could defeat any of the best poets from mythology, and even Pan would be judged inferior by Arcadia itself. The concluding verses 60–63 encourage the boy to smile at his parents and be worthy of dining with the gods.

Historical Context: The Treaty of Brundisium and Identity of the Child

This section provides a brief overview of the contemporary political situation to help situate the modern reader within the historical moment by considering why the poem addresses Gaius Asinius Pollio, a consul of Rome, in verse 12, and the possible identity of the male child the poem celebrates.

After Julius Caesar’s assassination on March 15, 44 BCE, various factions fought to gain control, plunging the Roman state into civil war. In November 43 BCE, Octavian, Antony, and Lepidus formed a triumvirate to settle the state and keep the peace (Appian, Civil Wars 4.1.2–3). This alliance rested on a careful balance of power between these three men, especially Octavian and Antony, both of whom had large, loyal armies.

The balance of power began to destabilize in the early summer of 40 BCE, the year of Gaius Asinius Pollio’s consulship. When the governor of Gaul died suddenly, Octavian took over the province, gaining its eleven legions in the process. Antony perceived Octavian’s acquisition of these legions as a serious threat, so he sailed with his legions from the East to Brundisium in southern Italy (modern-day Brindisi). By late summer of 40 BCE, Octavian and Antony were staging troops at Brundisium, and it was only due to the unwillingness of those troops to fight each other in another civil war that there was not an immediate battle. The troops called for a peaceful resolution, so negotiations between the two sides began. The consul Gaius Asinius Pollio negotiated on behalf of Antony, while Maecenas negotiated on behalf of Octavian (Appian, Civil Wars 5.7.64). In autumn 40 BCE a pact was made, the Treaty of Brundisium, that reaffirmed the triumvirate and divided up the empire between the three men: Octavian in the west, Lepidus in North Africa, and Antony in the east (Appian, Civil Wars 5.7.65, Dio 48.28.3–29.1). The agreement was sealed with the political marriage of Octavian’s sister, Octavia, to Antony. The hoped-for son of Antony and Octavia is a likely candidate for the poem’s child.

As we turn to the major themes and imagery of Vergil’s Eclogue 4, we should keep in mind how the poem was written against the backdrop of the recent civil wars, the consul Pollio’s role in the Treaty of Brundisium, and the promise of peace tied to the marriage of Octavia and Antony.

As a postscript to this overview of the state of political affairs: Octavia and Antony never did have a son (they had two girls, Antonia Maior, born in 39 BCE, and Antonia Minor, born in 36 BCE). Civil war between Antony and Octavian erupted for the last time in 31 BCE, with Octavian finally defeating Antony and Cleopatra at the Battle of Actium and securing his position as the sole ruler of Rome.

While Antony and Octavia’s anticipated male child is perhaps the most likely candidate for the identity of Eclogue 4’s child, many possibilities have been proposed. In fact, a productive reading proposed by some scholars is to embrace the ambiguity of the child’s identity when reading the poem. According to the later ancient scholar Servius, when Eclogue 4 first appeared, the son of the consul Pollio, Asinius Gallus, put himself forward as the leading candidate for the child celebrated in the poem. Other Roman readers thought it could be the child of Octavian and his first wife, Scribonia. In the centuries after Vergil, the poem took on a whole new life within the Christian tradition, as various Christian figures, most prominently the Roman Emperor Constantine, explored the possibility that Eclogue 4 prophesied the birth of Jesus. Eclogue 4 soon became known as the “Messianic” Eclogue and secured Vergil a place in the Christian imagination as a pagan prophet.

The Pastoral Tradition and Theocritus

Eclogue 4 is a type of poem called pastoral or bucolic, which has come to mean poems written in a playful, rustic style, often in the voice of a shepherd or other denizen of the rural countryside. In the first three poems of Vergil’s Eclogues we meet shepherds and travelers who sing songs to each other that express their hardships, their humorous poetic skill, and their romantic love. In the first verse of Eclogue 4 Vergil announces a move away from these topics and invokes the pastoral Muses to “let us sing of somewhat greater things” (verse 1). Vergil then boldly asserts that the poem’s topic will be “worthy of a consul” (verse 3). On the one hand, this opening might seem jarring after three poems featuring singing shepherds; on the other hand, this sharp change of topic is in line with the pastoral genre itself, as seen in the pastoral poems of Vergil’s great literary model, the Hellenistic poet Theocritus (c. 300–250 BCE).

Theocritus, a Greek poet from Syracuse, in Sicily, wrote poems in the style of traditional shepherd songs and singing contests, called pastoral or bucolic poetry. Theocritus’s poems are called the Idylls, or “little poems.” While many idylls depict singing shepherds, the themes and subject matter of his poems are in fact quite varied, including love spells (Idyll 2), town life (Idyll 15), the infant Heracles (Idyll 24).Theocritus also wrote an encomiastic poem, Idyll 17, that celebrates the reign of King Ptolemy II of Egypt and serves as an important model for Vergil’s Eclogue 4. In verses 9–12 of Idyll 17, Theocritus blends a rustic simile with his poetic undertaking to praise Ptolemy:

῎Ιδαν ἐς πολύδενδρον ἀνὴρ ὑλατόμος ἐλθὼν

παπταίνει, παρεόντος ἄδην, πόθεν ἄρξεται ἔργου.

τί πρῶτον καταλέξω; ἐπεὶ πάρα μυρία εἰπεῖν,

οἷσι θεοὶ τὸν ἄριστον ἐτίμησαν βασιλήων.

The woodman who enters Ida’s forest is overwhelmed by plenty,

And looks about him to see where he should begin his work.

What must I first describe among the countless gifts

Which the gods have showered on this supreme of kings? (trans. Verity).

Likewise, Vergil connects the rustic elements of pastoral to a more elevated topic in verses 1–3:

Sicelides Musae, paulo maiora canamus!

non omnis arbusta iuvant humilesque myricae;

si canimus silvas, silvae sint consule dignae.

“Sicilian Muses, let us sing of somewhat greater things!

Not everyone enjoys groves and humble tamarisks;

If we sing of the woods, let the woods be worthy of a consul.

Moreover, by calling the Muses “Sicilian,” he connects his poetry to that of Theocritus, who was from Sicily.

Only the greatest of poets is skilled enough to celebrate the deeds of an exceptional ruler to garner him the proper honors. So, in his praise of Ptolemy in Idyll 17, Theocritus, makes clear that he possesses such skill at verses 5–8:

ἥρωες, τοὶ πρόσθεν ἀφ᾽ ἡμιθέων ἐγένοντο,

ῥέξαντες καλὰ ἔργα σοφῶν ἐκύρησαν ἀοιδῶν:

αὐτὰρ ἐγὼ Πτολεμαῖον ἐπιστάμενος καλὰ εἰπεῖν

ὑμνήσαιμ᾽: ὕμνοι δὲ καὶ ἀθανάτων γέρας αὐτῶν.

Heroes of former times, children of demigods, had skillful poets

To celebrate their glorious deeds; I too possess that art,

And it is Ptolemy I must celebrate in my hymns—

For hymns are a reward even among the gods. (trans. Verity)

Just as Theocritus described himself as worthy of praising Ptolemy, so too Vergil describes his own poetic worthiness at the end of Eclogue 4 where he claims he could beat mythic poets in poetic contests at verses 55–56: non me carminibus vincet nec Thracius Orpheus / nec Linus (“neither Thracian Orpheus nor Linus will defeat me in song”). These claims of poetic authority emphasize the greatness of the topic.

The Golden Age

In addition to declaring his own poetic greatness, Vergil also elevates the poem to loftier topics through the myth of a returning Golden Age and golden race of men. Vergil’s contemporary Roman audience would recognize many features of his Golden Age, as there was a long Greek poetic tradition of describing human history as a series of worsening ages populated by metallic races of men, starting with an idyllic golden race that devolves into the contemporary iron race, characterized by hardship and strife. Vergil introduces a major innovation by claiming that this Golden Age and golden race will return. In his major literary models, the poems of Hesiod, Aratus, and Catullus, the Golden Age is in the mythical past; men living in the contemporary age of iron must embrace suffering and competition for scarce resources which necessitates law, government, and cultural mechanisms to regulate this scarcity and reward hard work.

Drawing upon Near Eastern mythology and poetry, the Greek poet Hesiod (8th-7th century BCE) first recounts the myth of the metallic ages of man. Hesiod begins with a golden race, followed successively by the silver and bronze races, then the age of heroes, and finally the iron race, each generation worse than the one before (Works and Days, 110–202). Zeus’ father Cronus (Saturn for the Romans) rules over the Golden Age, in which the golden race of men are like gods, free from pain and suffering and ageless. In Hesiod’s Golden Age, “every good thing was theirs; / the barley-giving earth asked for no toil to bring forth / a rich and plentiful harvest” (117–119, Athanassakis, trans.). This emphasis on the bounty of nature in the Golden Age is a central feature of Eclogue 4 (for example, verses 18–19).

Another important feature of Eclogue 4’s Golden Age is the return of “The Maiden,” or Virgo (verse 6), who is to be identified with Justice, as we shall see. The figure of Virgo would be familiar to Vergil’s Roman readers from the poetry of Aratus, who himself draws upon Hesiod’s ages of man. Aratus (circa 315–240 BCE) wrote a didactic poem about the constellations and weather signs called Phaenomena, popular among educated Roman elites in Vergil’s time. Some people, says Aratus, hold that constellation The Maiden (Παρθένον) was known as Justice (Δίκη). She once walked among the men of the golden race (Aratus, Phaenomena, verses 96–136). In Aratus the men of the Golden Age neither quarrel nor desire more than they need: “the oxen and the plough and Justice herself, queen of the peoples, giver of things just, abundantly supplied their every need” (Aratus, Phaenomena, verses 112–113, trans. Mair). As the ages and races of men deteriorate from gold to silver to bronze, Justice (Virgo) withdraws from man until finally, in the bronze age, she retreats to the stars. Thus, when we learn in verse 6 of Eclogue 4 that Virgo now returns, we know that she brings with her the returning peaceful Golden Age.

Whereas Aratus emphasizes the role of Justice within the Golden Age, the Roman poet Catullus (circa 84–54 BCE) in his poem 64 explores the Age of Heroes as a moment of transition to the violence and suffering of the contemporary Iron Age. Catullus 64 is a mini-epic celebrating the mythical marriage of the Greek hero Peleus to the sea nymph Thetis, the future parents of the Greek hero Achilles. A large portion of the poem recounts the story of Theseus abandoning Ariadne on the island of Naxos after she helped him defeat the Minotaur in the labyrinth, as woven on a coverlet draped over the marriage bed of Peleus and Thetis (Catullus 64.50–264). The poem then returns to the wedding of Peleus and Thetis, where the Fates weave a prophecy predicting Achilles’ violent role in the Trojan War (Catullus 64.323–381), and the poem concludes with the poet lamenting the contemporary age in comparison to even the Age of Heroes (Catullus 64.384). Unlike in Hesiod, the poet acknowledges the violence of the Heroic age, when, for example, the Fates describe Achilles’ actions in Trojan war, culminating in his sacrifice of Polyxena (64.336–370). Nevertheless, in the Age of Heroes gods visited “the morally pure homes of heroes” (Catullus 64.384–385). Now the gods no longer do so because in these corrupt times, “brothers bathe their hands with their brother’s blood” among other crimes (Catullus 64.399). Catullus 64, therefore, is an important precedent for Eclogue 4 in that it celebrates a marriage that will produce an important child, it recounts the decline from the Golden Age to the contemporary age of civil strife, highlights the violence of the Age of Heroes, and it employs the language of prophecy.

Just as Catullus employed prophetic language (currite ducentes subtegmina, currite, fusi, “Run, drawing the weft out, run, you spindles!” 64.327, trans. Green), so too Eclogue 4 describes the Fates urging on their prophetic weaving: 'Talia saecla' suis dixerunt 'currite' fusis, (“ ‘Cause such ages to run,” they said to their spindles,” verse 46). Where Catullus employs the language of prophecy to celebrate the birth of Achilles and set up the concluding lament for the depraved state of contemporary humanity, Vergil reverses this trajectory so that the child’s birth signals the end of this current age of strife and the return of the Golden Age, after passing through a period of renewed, heroic warfare. Before the child reaches adulthood, however, “nevertheless, a few traces of former deceit will linger” (verse 31). Even with natural abundance, until the child reaches adulthood, humanity will violate the natural order by using technology to travel the sea, partition the land, and plow the earth; there will be a period of renewed heroic warfare, including a second Trojan War and a second voyage of the Argo, both allusions to Catullus 64.

Prophecy and Cosmic Rebirth

Eclogue 4’s central prophecy weaves together hope for political peace and prosperity with the dawning of a new cosmic age. Vergil declares at verse 4: Ultima Cumaei venit iam carminis aetas (“the final age of the Cumaean song has now come"); the phrase “Cumaean song” evokes the prophecies of the Sibyl of Cumae that pertain to the wellbeing of the Roman state and comes from a prophetic tradition deeply ingrained in Rome’s past. According to tradition, this female prophet sold the official Sibylline prophecies, recorded in Greek hexameter verse, to King Tarquin Superbus, the seventh king of Rome. The prophecies were kept in the temple of Jupiter Optimus Maximus on the Capitoline hill in Rome and were consulted in times of great national crisis (Dionysius of Halicarnassus, Roman Antiquities, 4.62). The temple burned in 83 BCE and the prophecies were destroyed, but they were reconstructed through fragments collected from across the Empire. To a Roman audience, this mention of the Sibyl of Cumae makes clear this song is a prophecy concerning the welfare of the Roman state and is of the utmost importance to Roman political leaders.

The phrase “the final age of the Cumaean song” signals cosmic rebirth: the prophesied final age is in fact a magnus ab integro saeclorum nascitur ordo (“great succession of ages born anew,” verse 5). The Golden Age has been reborn, ushered in by the birth of a boy (verses 8–9).

While Vergil’s known literary sources do not include the idea of a reborn Golden Age, this notion of cyclical time and ages born anew can be traced back to two distinct traditions familiar to Vergil’s audience. One is the astrological concept of the Great Year when all celestial bodies (planets and stars) together occupy the same position as they did at a previous moment in time (Cicero, De Re Publica 6.24; Cicero, De Natura Deorum 2.51). The Stoics had a related concept for their idea of the fiery destruction and rebirth of the universe that will occur when the celestial bodies return to their original positions at the birth of the universe.

The second important concept is the saeculum (spelled saeclum in Eclogue 4), featured together with the concept of the Great Year (magnus annus) in verse 5: magnus ab integro saeclorum nascitur ordo, “a great succession of ages is born anew.” Etruscan prophetic tradition held that the Etruscan nation would exist for a period of ten ages or saecula, the approximate upper limit of a human lifetime, 100–110 years, at the end of which the Etruscan nation would come to an end (Censorinus, De die natali 17.5–6).

These references to cyclic ages and time do not suggest a specific worldview or philosophical understanding of the nature of time. Rather, Vergil draws upon familiar, relevant language and ideas to foreground how truly new and profoundly significant on a cosmic scale this historical moment is; this is a new era, but a new era that hearkens back to the past while generating excitement for what is to come.

In addition to Eclogue 4’s poetic allusions to the Golden Age from Greek and Roman poetry, there are intriguing correspondences between Eclogue 4 and the Book of Isaiah in the Hebrew Scriptures: is there a connection? R.G.M. Nisbet (2008) argues there may be. Prophetic poetry produced by Greek-speaking Jews in Egypt, celebrating the birth of a boy, a Messiah, who will bring the kingdom of heaven to earth, were circulating in Vergil’s Rome, which Nisbet argues have compelling poetic correspondences with Vergil’s Eclogue 4. Called ‘Sibylline oracles’ (not to be confused with the official Sibylline oracles discussed earlier) and written in Greek, these poems drew heavily from Jewish religious texts. Some points of connection between these poems and Eclogue 4 are: a miraculous child overseeing the return of a Golden Age (kingdom of heaven on earth), and predator and prey living in harmony. Moreover, the Jewish tradition allows for a permanent ideal state (Nisbet 2008). If we accept these possible connections, we can then understand Vergil’s poetic project of Eclogue 4 to be one of creating an expansive, innovative prophecy of cosmic and political rebirth. Vergil potentially draws upon these Jewish poems for the imagery and narrative of a human birth that ushers in a new cosmic and earthly era.

Most important for us as modern readers is to be aware of and sensitive to Vergil’s powerful language and novel reworkings of literary and mythical traditions in his Eclogue 4. Vergil creates something entirely new here: a poem that celebrates the rebirth of the mythic Golden Age in a concrete political context, in a specific time and place on Earth. Until this moment, the Golden Age of Greek and Roman myth was anchored firmly in the deep recesses of the past, but now, through his poetic innovation and textual allusions, Vergil can bring the mythic Golden Age into the present moment, celebrating the potential of this new political moment to bring out a wondrous new era for Rome.

Very Select Bibliography

The bibliography on Vergil is vast. The following works, all in English, were used in preparing this introduction and commentary or offer helpful starting points for further reading. Volk (2008) surveys twentieth-century scholarship; Smith (2011, chap. 3) and Cucchiarelli (2023) provide additional overviews of the Eclogues.

Clausen, Wendell. 1994. A Commentary on Virgil, Eclogues. Oxford University Press. An excellent source for understanding the influence of Hellenistic poetry, especially Theocritus, on Vergil’s Eclogues.

Coleman, Robert. 1977. Vergil: Eclogues. Cambridge University Press. Introduction and commentary on Vergil’s Eclogues, including quotations from Greek and Roman poetry and Jewish texts.

Courtney, Edward. 2010. “A Basic Approach to the Fourth Eclogue.” Vergilius 56: 27–38. A very helpful reading guide to Eclogue 4.

Cucchiarelli, Andrea. 2023. A Commentary on Virgil’s Eclogues. Oxford University Press. An up-to-date and detailed scholarly commentary on the Eclogues.

Kallendorf, Craig. 2015. The Protean Virgil: Material Form and the Reception of the Classics. Oxford University Press. Pages 48–58 provide an overview of Eclogue 4 in Christian thought and culture, with additional bibliography at p. 50 n. 17.

Martindale, Charles, ed. 1997. The Cambridge Companion to Virgil. Cambridge University Press. A collection of essays on a variety of topics related to Virgil’s poetry.

Nisbet, R. G. M. 2008. “Virgil’s Fourth Eclogue: Easterners and Westerners.” In Vergil’s Eclogues, edited by Katharina Volk, 155–88. Oxford University Press. A thorough overview of possible Greek, Roman, and Jewish influences on Eclogue 4.

Page, T. E. 1963. P. Vergili Maronis Bucolica et Georgica. Macmillan. First published 1898.

Perkell, Christine. 2002. “The Golden Age and Its Contradictions in the Poetry of Vergil.” Vergilius 48: 3–39. A theory-informed reading of the complexities and tensions within Vergil’s Golden Ages.

Petrini, Mark. 1997. The Child and the Hero: Coming of Age in Catullus and Vergil. University of Michigan Press. Chapter 5 discusses the child’s development in Eclogue 4 and the poem’s connection with Catullus 64.

Ryberg, I. S. 1958. “Vergil’s Golden Age.” Transactions and Proceedings of the American Philological Association 89: 112–31.

Smith, R. Alden. 2011. Virgil. Wiley-Blackwell. Chapter 3 provides an overview of the Eclogues and analyses of individual poems.

Volk, Katharina, ed. 2008. Vergil’s Eclogues. Oxford University Press. Oxford Readings in Classical Studies. A collection of influential scholarly articles on Vergil’s Eclogues; the introduction surveys major trends in scholarship.

Wallace-Hadrill, Andrew. 1982. “The Golden Age and Sin in Augustan Ideology.” Past & Present 95: 19–36. Explores the cultural context for Golden Age imagery in Augustan Rome.

Ziolkowski, Jan M., and Michael C. J. Putnam, eds. 2008. The Virgilian Tradition: The First Fifteen Hundred Years. Yale University Press. Pages 487–503 contain primary sources on the reception of the Eclogues through 1500.